From previous experience, either configuration will support the volume of hosts and checks you've described. So other factors need to be considered -- like cost, supportability and ease of administration. From an installation perspective, I find that the majority of Nagios users seem to prefer Linux-based (and Red Hat is amongst the most popular) installations.
This Nagios User Profiles page shows some statistics on this and indicates that 30% of users who registered use Nagios on Red Hat and only 4.6% use Nagios on Solaris. From a support perspective, knowledge and responses on the mailing list and other forums do tend to be skewed toward Linux-based installations. As such, I'd recommend the Linux-based approach. Good luck with your installation.
Related Q&A from James Turnbull
A user wants to implement OSSEC on a Windows server because he has no server side Linux operating system.continue reading
Solaris 10 Trusted Extensions and SELinux are best suited to different system requirements and administrator skill sets. Our security expert explains...continue reading
Configuring spam filters Spamassassin and dspam together in the email server Postfix is easy with the resources listed by our security expert.continue reading
Have a question for an expert?
Please add a title for your question
Get answers from a TechTarget expert on whatever's puzzling you.